Its really hard to find a good chew. They all have there downs. Either break teeth, smell...they all are choking hazards so I always use supervision. I won't ever give my dog a Chewie from China ....that would be the worst imo. Knowing they can use chemicals illegal here. I tried butcher jerky but not chewy enough. Nyla bones if your dog can't chew them up I think would be okay. But my dogs don't like them. The Himalayan chew doesn't seem bad but to much cheese and heavy chewers can make a mess....My puppy like it but Moki makes a mess....Pigs hoves or ear can have bacteria or splinter....I'm just gonna tag along till something good comes up....