Yeah it is tough! Everything Nolee gets is destroyed. I received a reindeer for the last GE. It had no stuffing, Nolee loves it and it still is entach! I guess b/c they were born to hunt, everything will be destroyed. All I can have for Nolee are tendons, bully sticks and tripe. The non stuffed raindeer has lasted the longest as for as toys. I am still looking for non stuffed toys! Good Luck!